HomeProfessional ProfilesPractice AreasFirm NewsLegal AlertsResources

 

        AT&T VoIP Subject to Access

 

On April 21, 2004, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) released an Order denying an AT&T petition for declaratory ruling that the company’s phone-to-phone Internet protocol (IP) telephony service is exempt from terminating access charges.

AT&T’s phone-to-phone IP telephony service involves three main steps.  First, a customer initiates an interexchange call by dialing 1+ the called number from an ordinary telephone via the public switched telephone network (PSTN).  Second, AT&T converts the call into IP format and routes the call over the company’s Internet backbone.  Third, AT&T converts the call back from IP format and routes it via the PSTN to the called party’s local exchange carrier for termination at the called number.  For this third step, AT&T unilaterally decided not to pay access charges to the called party’s local exchange carrier.

AT&T argued that it did not have to pay access charges because its IP telephony service is an unregulated “information service” and not a “telecommunications service.”  However, the FCC was not persuaded.  It concluded that AT&T’s telephony service met the statutory definition of a “telecommunications service” because the service: “(1) uses ordinary customer premises equipment (CPE) with no enhanced functionality; (2) originates and terminates on the public switched telephone network (PSTN); and (3) undergoes no net protocol conversion and provides no enhanced functionality to end users due to the provider’s use of IP technology.”

After concluding that AT&T was providing a telecommunications service, the FCC reasoned that AT&T should “pay the same interstate access charges as other interexchange carriers for the same termination of calls” as required by FCC regulation (47 C.F.R. § 69.5(b)).  The FCC did not reach a conclusion as to whether its Order exposes AT&T to retroactive liability for unpaid access charges because such a determination will differ from case-to-case.

The FCC’s decision would appear to suggest that VoIP or IP telephony services which transmit calls that originate and terminate on the PSTN, and that otherwise involve no enhanced functionality, will be viewed as regulated telecommunications services.  However, the Order made clear that the decision was based upon the specific facts presented by AT&T’s IP telephony service and does not preclude the FCC from reaching a contrary conclusion in its ongoing, broader IP-Enabled Services proceeding.

The text of the FCC’s Order can be viewed at

http://hraunfoss.fcc.gov/edocs_public/attachmatch/FCC-04-97A1.pdf.

April 2004

Back